After listening to your feedback, we've decided to readjust the Victory Star Bonus modifications in patch 5.0. We're going to further increase the amount of Victory stars awarded based on your opponent's Heart and League level.
The 5.0 patch notes have already been adjusted with the new values. Also please note that once the update goes Live, the tournament qualifying thresholds will be adjusted accordingly.
Your feedback is a much appreciated (and integral) part of our continued quest to improve Dungeon Keeper. Thanks for all of your thoughts and concerns-- as always, we'll be listening, and we'll make these kinds of improvements whenever possible.